Nintendo Wii forums Forum for writers phpBB mods Essays on copyright Dating advice Narnia forums

Dungeons & Dragons 3.t, turning rules streamlined

For a while now, I've been mulling over what I would do to make D&D 3.5 play faster, like 4th edition promised.  Of course, the joke is that 4th edition can be even slower than 3.5, due to all the new movement rules.  But I don't have to worry about that.  I just want to take the best elements, and graft them onto the 3.5 rules with a minimum of fuss.

I'm calling my revisions 3.t, as in 3.tony, because I'm the one to blame if the revisions suck or work well.  The criteria for "sucks" would be if a rule change requires large rewrites, or breaks lots of other rules.  The criteria for "works well" would be if a rule change speeds up gameplay but has little effect otherwise.  So if a typical combat takes 90 minutes to resolve normally, with my rules I hope that you can resolve combat in an hour or less.

Turning

First up for revision is the cleric system for turning undead.  We merely drop the turn check roll, and replace it with cleric level + charisma bonus + knowledge religion synergy (if the character has it).  The turn damage roll would remain.  So the steps are as follows:

  1. Roll the turn damage as usual (2d6 + cleric level + charisma).
  2. Cap the highest hit die undead that can be turned at: cleric level + charisma modifier + knowledge religion synergy (if any).

Let's consider the example of a 2nd level cleric with 14 charisma and no points in the knowledge religion skill.  If the cleric rolled a 4, he'd have an 8 for step 1 (4 + 2 for level, +2 for charisma).  Then for step 2 the cap would be set at 2 + 2 + 0 (no synergy bonus), or 4 total.  Therefore, the cleric could turn two 4 HD undead (8 total, capped at 4 HD).  But he/she could not turn one 8 HD undead, due to the per-monster cap.

This is almost exactly the same as turn undead following RAW, but removes one roll and replaces it with a reasonably fair, typically unchanging number.  Should be easier for players to follow and execute quickly.

I'll group all my articles about rules revision under the 3.t tag, should you wish to see what else I have for it.

Navigate

« Reggie to the Wii: "I brought you into this world, and I can take you out!" | Main | Dungeons & Dragons 3.t, critical hits streamlined »

Nav by tag: 35_edition
Main
Nav by tag: 3t
Main | Dungeons & Dragons 3.t, critical hits streamlined »
Nav by tag: d20
Main | Dungeons & Dragons 3.t, critical hits streamlined »
Nav by tag: dungeons_and_dragons
« Dungeons & Dragons: 4th edition review | Main | Dungeons & Dragons 3.t, critical hits streamlined »
Nav by tag: srd
Main | Dungeons & Dragons 3.t, critical hits streamlined »
Bookmark It! Technorati del.icio.us Netvouz DZone ThisNext Wists blinkbits BlinkList blogmarks blogtercimlap Blue Dot Bumpzee co.mments connotea DotNetKicks Fark feedmelinks Fleck Furl Gwar Haohao Hemidemi IndiaGram IndianPad Internetmedia kick.ie LinkaGoGo Linkter Ma.gnolia MyShare Netscape NewsVine PlugIM PopCurrent ppnow RawSugar Reddit Shadows Simpy Slashdot Smarking Spurl Webride YahooMyWeb
TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.outshine.com/cgi-bin/outshine/trackback.cgi/81

Comments (23)
PMDM writes:

Check out Unearthed Arcana, they have a variant turning level check similar to yours. Although from my read through, it is no less complex than the original. It requires you to turn each undead as an individual check, which would require More dice rolling!

Check it out next game.


PMDM writes:

Ah, a page # - UA 66-67


aboyd [TypeKey Profile Page] writes:

Thanks PMDM. The variant rules in Unearthed Arcana are interesting but much slower.

It was good to read the variant rules, as it alerted me to a quirk I had overlooked -- paladins can turn undead too. So I thought I might use this comment to correct my oversight. Anyone using a paladin can use my system for turning with a minor change to the text. In steps 1 & 2, change "cleric level" to "paladin level -3" and it works just fine.


Starly Jackson writes:

And while the idea is not to turn D&D into an MMORPG--a massively multiplayer online game--like World of Warcraft or EverQuest, there can be no doubt that
Andy Collins, a member of the fourth-edition design team, told me the major idea behind the new edition is to streamline D&D so that there is less abstraction
3 Since the year 2001, the majority of the books being released by wizards had MASSIVE editing errors, entire chapters littered with "cut and paste" fall out
If that wasn't a hint that WOTC is saying "our DM's are incompetent and can't arbitrate rules- let's take those out", I don't know what is


AswadKannah writes:

Hey - I am really delighted to discover this. great job!


ASSITYSNIRL writes:

OMG, it is still accepting donations! Fantastic example of a creative fundraising effort that raised $10,000 in 48 hours to build a classroom at the school in Tanzania.


Useful info. Hope to see more good posts in the future.


Peter writes:

And what's the problem, rlealy?This request is very honest and clear about the conditions. No foul play, if you ask me.Whoever thinks that such a thing is immoral or whatever doesn't have to apply, right?Again, what's the problem?


Fell out of bed feeling down. This has brightened my day!


mobile writes:

You're the greatest! JMHO


Posts like this make the internet such a treasure trove


home insurance writes:

I don't even know what to say, this made things so much easier!


Alright alright alright that's exactly what I needed!


A few years ago I'd have to pay someone for this information.


Thought it wouldn't to give it a shot. I was right.


Fell out of bed feeling down. This has brightened my day!


That's an expert answer to an interesting question


As Charlie Sheen says, this article is "WINNING!"


Great hammer of Thor, that is powerfully helpful!


Thanky Thanky for all this good information!


That's really thinking of the highest order


I don't know who you wrote this for but you helped a brother out.


Post a comment

Verification (needed to reduce spam):